Monday 28 April 2014

Similar Signatures

There are a number of free fronts which are commonly mistaken for one another, none more so than the following two examples. When viewed in isolation it can be seen how they could be confused but when seen together as below there are a number of marked differences.


General Sir James Willoughby Gordon, Quarter-Master General to the Forces 1811 - 1851 - MP for Launceston 1829 - 1831



On close inspection the 'J' which precedes the 'W' on  Sir James Willoughby Gordon's signature (top) makes a third vertical line preceding the 'Gordon' part of the signature whereas in the case of William Gordon (bottom) there are only two such vertical lines. Other giveaways include the heavy underlining of  Sir James Willoughby Gordon's signature as well as elsewhere on the envelope front (top). Another giveaway is if William Gordon's front is sent from Aberdeen, although this example is sent from London a great many examples that I've seen are addressed from Aberdeen. Usually the dates of course are another key clue in correctly identifying the signature, however in this case the two men were in office at the same time as one another for a very long time, from 1820 to 1851 in fact. Clearly though an example prior to 1820 is likely to be that of Sir James Willoughby Gordon and similarly one dated after 1851 couldn't be his.